What the EU ESG Ratings Regulation means for rated companies
The EU now supervises ESG rating providers. What the new rules change for rated companies, what stays the same, and how to prepare.
Since 2 July 2026, the providers of ESG ratings in the EU have been subject to binding rules for the first time. The EU ESG Ratings Regulation targets the providers, not the companies they rate. Yet anyone whose company is assessed by EcoVadis, MSCI, Sustainalytics or CDP will feel its effects.
ESG ratings now shape everyday business decisions. Customers use them to select suppliers, while investors and banks draw on them when assessing companies. Until now, however, it was often unclear how a score came about and what data it was based on. The new regulation is designed to change that.
Why the EU stepped in
ESG ratings have become a central reference point in sustainable finance. When the regulation was adopted, the UN-supported Principles for Responsible Investment alone had more than 5,300 signatories representing over EUR 120 trillion in assets under management (European Parliament & Council of the European Union, 2024). Many of these investors use ESG ratings to select and monitor their investments.
Confidence in the ratings, however, was limited. A study commissioned by the European Commission in 2021 identified conflicts of interest, a lack of transparency and accuracy in methodologies, and unclear terminology as key weaknesses of the market (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024). In the Commission’s 2022 public consultation, stakeholders confirmed their concerns about the lack of transparency of ESG rating methodologies (European Parliament & Council of the European Union, 2024).
The ratings also diverge considerably. A 2021 MIT study cited by Freshfields found an average divergence of 39% between ESG ratings, compared with just 1% for credit ratings (Seibt et al., 2023). For a rated company, this means that the same sustainability performance can lead to very different scores depending on the provider. Against this background, the European Commission presented its proposal for regulating ESG rating providers on 13 June 2023 (Seibt et al., 2023).
What the regulation covers
Regulation (EU) 2024/3005 on the transparency and integrity of ESG rating activities entered into force on 1 January 2025 and has applied since 2 July 2026. It requires ESG rating providers that serve investors and companies in the EU to be authorised and supervised by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) (European Commission, n.d.).
In the sense of the regulation, an ESG rating is an opinion or a score on the environmental, social and governance profile of a company or financial product that is based on an established methodology and a defined system of rating categories (Seibt et al., 2023). The rules apply regardless of how a rating is used. This matters because many companies encounter ESG ratings not through investors but through supplier assessments requested by their customers (EcoVadis, n.d.). Private ratings not intended for publication, raw ESG data without a rating element and ratings used exclusively for certification fall outside the scope (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024; Seibt et al., 2023). Providers based outside the EU can only offer their ratings in the EU through an equivalence decision, endorsement by an authorised EU entity or recognition (WilmerHale, 2024).
The regulation rests on three pillars. Providers need ESMA authorisation and are subject to its ongoing supervision, including inspections and requests for information. They must publish their methodologies, models and key rating assumptions, and review their methodologies at least once a year (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024). And they must keep rating activities separate from other services such as consulting, credit ratings, benchmarks, audit and insurance within the same legal entity. This separation applies at entity level, so other companies in the same group may still offer such services if information barriers are in place (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024).
The sanctions are significant. ESMA can impose fines of up to 10% of a provider’s total annual net turnover for intentional or negligent breaches, as well as periodic penalty payments to enforce its decisions (WilmerHale, 2024). Providers must also keep records of their rating activities for at least five years and operate a complaints-handling mechanism. Complaints may concern, for example, the data sources behind a specific rating or the way its methodology was applied (Seibt et al., 2023).
Further requirements aim to make ratings easier to compare. Providers must state whether a rating addresses financial risks to the rated company, its impact on the environment and society, or both, a concept known as double materiality. They must also disclose whether a rating considers alignment with the Paris Agreement, with the core conventions of the International Labour Organization and with international standards on tax evasion (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024). ESG rating information will also become available through the European Single Access Point (ESAP), a central EU platform that already provides access to sustainability disclosures under the CSRD and SFDR (WilmerHale, 2024). Providers are, however, not required to disclose trade secrets (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024).
The model is familiar from credit ratings. Since July 2011, ESMA has been solely responsible for registering and supervising credit rating agencies in the EU, and it has used its enforcement powers, for example by fining Moody’s €1.24 million for breaches of the credit rating rules (European Securities and Markets Authority [ESMA], 2019). ESG ratings now follow the same path. For companies, this is a clear signal that ESG scores are increasingly treated as information on which markets rely, much like credit ratings. Before the regulation, there were international recommendations and voluntary codes of conduct, but no binding EU framework for ESG rating providers.
Timeline and current status
The major providers have notified ESMA and are now going through its authorisation process.
- 2 November 2026Deadline for existing providers to submit their authorisation application
- 2 August 2026Deadline for existing providers to notify ESMA of their intention to apply
- 2 July 2026Regulation applies
- 1 January 2025Regulation enters into force
- 12 December 2024Publication in the Official Journal of the EU
Table 1: Timetable
Providers that notified ESMA in time may continue to issue ratings while their applications are assessed. Third parties may also keep distributing those ratings until ESMA has decided on the respective application (A&O Shearman, 2026). For companies, nothing changes abruptly: existing ratings remain in use, while the new obligations gradually become visible in the way providers communicate with rated companies.
Among the best-known providers, Sustainalytics moved early and submitted its application in September 2026, covering among others its ESG Risk Ratings and Controversy Ratings (Morningstar Sustainalytics, 2026). EcoVadis notified ESMA in July 2026 and expects a decision around May 2027 (EcoVadis, n.d.). MSCI issues its ESG ratings in the EU through MSCI Solutions (Deutschland) GmbH and has already published a policy setting out how it notifies companies before their first rating (MSCI, n.d.). CDP has announced that it will apply for authorisation for its scores (CDP, n.d.).
Notification, however, is not the same as authorisation. Until ESMA has decided, companies should check its register for the current status of a provider rather than rely on announcements.
What changes for rated companies
Rated companies gain insight into how they are assessed and formal ways to correct errors. Four changes stand out.
Transparent methodologies. Providers must disclose the data sources, assumptions and weightings behind their ratings. Companies can see, for example, how much climate action counts compared with working conditions, and whether a rating looks at financial risks, at impacts on society and the environment, or at both. It should also become possible to verify the data used in a rating, without being able to influence its outcome (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024). MSCI, for instance, offers rated companies information on data sources, the use of estimates and the date of the last update free of charge on request (MSCI, n.d.).
E, S and G shown separately. Providers either rate the environmental, social and governance dimensions separately or disclose the weight of each component in an overall score in enough detail to allow comparison (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024). Companies can see more clearly where they gain and lose points, and whether a strong score in one area is masking weaknesses in another.
A fact-check window. Before an ESG rating issued on or after 2 July 2026 is published for the first time, the provider must notify the rated company at least two full working days in advance. Ratings issued before that date must be submitted for a fact-check at least once when they are next updated, and again after a material change in methodology (ESMA, 2025).
A formal complaints route. Where a company believes a rating rests on incorrect data or a misapplied methodology, it can use the provider’s complaints-handling mechanism, which the regulation makes mandatory (Seibt et al., 2023). EcoVadis, for example, states that it acknowledges complaints within two working days and decides on them within ten (EcoVadis, n.d.).
What does not change
The new transparency only helps companies that are prepared to use it. Several things remain as they were.
Two working days is short. Once the notification period has passed, the provider may publish the rating without waiting for a response (ESMA, 2026). The provider must review a company’s feedback carefully, but it is not obliged to change the rating. Anyone who only starts collecting figures and evidence when the notification arrives will struggle to respond in time.
Methodologies still differ. The regulation does not prescribe a single methodology, and it explicitly protects the independence of providers. A company can still score well with one provider and lower with another. The difference is that the reasons should now be easier to trace.
Your data remains your responsibility. The regulation governs how providers work, not the quality of the information companies submit in questionnaires. Incomplete, outdated or inconsistent answers will continue to cost points.
Many companies are rated without taking part. Providers such as MSCI and Sustainalytics rely largely on publicly available information. EcoVadis also generates supplier risk profiles from public data when buyers screen their supply chains, and companies can register free of charge to view and correct these profiles (EcoVadis, n.d.). Many small and medium-sized companies are likely unaware that such profiles exist.
What companies should expect and how to prepare
For most companies, the first visible effect will be a message from a rating provider. Anyone rated for the first time, or whose existing rating is next updated, should expect a notification with a short deadline to check the underlying data. Companies that already know which providers rate them, including those that assess them without their involvement, will be able to respond with far less pressure.
Preparation therefore starts with an overview: which ratings exist, who asked for them and how much weight customers, investors and banks give them. The second step is clear responsibility. Someone needs to receive provider notifications and be able to respond within two working days, including during holiday periods. The third step is a well-maintained evidence base, with current figures, policies and certificates in one place, so that any correction can be backed up quickly.
Over time, companies can also use the new disclosures strategically. Published methodologies show which topics carry the most weight, and the complaints mechanism offers a formal route when a rating appears to rest on incorrect data. Companies that use these tools can focus their sustainability work on what actually moves their ratings.
Companies should also expect their ratings to move more visibly. Providers must review their methodologies at least once a year (Norton Rose Fulbright, 2024), and a material change in methodology triggers a new fact-check notification for existing ratings (ESMA, 2025). Over the coming years, more information on ESG ratings will also become accessible through ESAP (WilmerHale, 2024). Customers, investors and competitors will find it easier to compare ratings across providers, which will raise expectations of companies that perform poorly or cannot explain their results.
Before Your Next ESG Rating: 15 Things Worth Checking
- Your investors’ view
- Data behind the score
- Dialogue with analysts
- + 12 more
Get your free checklist
MOST POPULAR INSIGHTS
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
See where your preparation stands
New EU rules, yearly methodology reviews and a bar that keeps rising: ESG ratings now move more visibly, and late preparation is hard to make up. This checklist shows what to check before your next rating, from your public data to each rating’s own rules.

How R.A.T.E. supports you
R.A.T.E. helps you understand your ESG ratings, prioritise the ones that matter to your stakeholders and improve your performance in a targeted way. Get in touch to discuss how to prepare for your next rating.
References
A&O Shearman. (2026). ESMA statement on publication and distribution of ESG ratings during transition period. https://finreg.aoshearman.com/esma-statement-on-publication-and-distribution-of-esg-ratings-during-transition-period
CDP. (n.d.). Regulatory compliance and governance. Retrieved November 11, 2026, from https://www.cdp.net/en/about/regulatory-compliance-and-governance
EcoVadis. (n.d.). EU ESG Rating Regulation. Retrieved November 11, 2026, from https://ecovadis.com/trust-center/esma/
European Commission. (n.d.). ESG rating activities. Retrieved November 11, 2026, from https://finance.ec.europa.eu/sustainable-finance/tools-and-standards/esg-rating-activities_en
European Parliament & Council of the European Union. (2024). Regulation (EU) 2024/3005 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 November 2024 on the transparency and integrity of environmental, social and governance (ESG) rating activities, and amending Regulations (EU) 2019/2088 and (EU) 2023/2859. Official Journal of the European Union, L 2024/3005. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/3005/oj
European Securities and Markets Authority. (2019). ESMA fines Moody’s €1.24 million for credit ratings breaches. https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/library/esma71-99-466_esma_fines_moodys_eu1.24_million_for_credit_ratings_breaches.pdf
European Securities and Markets Authority. (2025). Application of two working day notification period (ESMA_QA_2719). https://www.esma.europa.eu/publications-data/questions-answers/2719
European Securities and Markets Authority. (2026). Scope of two working day notification period (ESMA_QA_2890). https://www.esma.europa.eu/publications-data/questions-answers/2890
Morningstar Sustainalytics. (2026, September 15). Morningstar Sustainalytics submits ESMA application. https://www.sustainalytics.com/esg-news/news-details/2026/09/15/morningstar-sustainalytics-submits-esma-application
MSCI. (n.d.). Prior notification and underlying data disclosure to first-time rated items policy. Retrieved November 11, 2026, from https://www.msci.com/downloads/documents/legal/sustainability-and-climate-resources-and-disclosures/policies-and-procedures/prior-notification-and-underlying-data-disclosure-to-first-time-rated-items-policy.pdf
Norton Rose Fulbright. (2024). Maybe capital markets lawyers can finally feel like super heroes. https://nortonrosefulbright.com/en/knowledge/publications/465c507c/maybe-capital-markets-lawyers-can-finally-feel-like-super-heroes
Seibt, C. H., Vesper-Gräske, M., Pettinger Kearney, N., & Schemmer, E. L. (2023, June 19). Reliability of ESG ratings? How the EU plans to regulate ESG rating providers. Freshfields. https://sustainability.freshfields.com/post/102ih4s/reliability-of-esg-ratings-how-the-eu-plans-to-regulate-esg-rating-providers
WilmerHale. (2024, December 10). EU adopts ESG Ratings Regulation: Strengthening transparency and reliability in sustainable finance. https://www.wilmerhale.com/en/insights/client-alerts/20241210-eu-adopts-esg-ratings-regulation-strengthening-transparency-and-reliability-in-sustainable-finance
Authors
Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!
Related articles
Nothing Found



